| Quartz | Solid Surface | Granite | Laminates | Butcher Block | |
|
Brand Names |
Cambria, Zodiaq Silestone, Caesarstone, Hanstone |
Corian, Living Stone, Meganite, Gibraltar, Avonite, Hi-Macs |
Many different |
Wilsonart, Formica, Pinoite |
Various |
|
What is it? |
Man-made: 93% crushed quartz witha resin binder |
Man-made: Acrylic or Polyester Plastics |
100% Natural stone quarried from the earth |
Man-made: Printed colors/patterns on a fiberglass backing |
Various species of 100% Natural wood |
|
Heat Resistance |
Can be affected by high heat (over 400F) |
Hot pots can warp, melt, crack, or discolor the surface |
Can be affected by high heat (over 400F) |
Hot pots can warp, melt, or discolor the surface |
Hot pots can burn the surface |
|
Cleanliness |
Non-porous - Best resistance to bacteria |
Non-porous - easy to clean. Favored in hospitals |
Very resistant to bacteria witd proper maintenance. |
Non-porous — easy to clean |
Initially good resistance to bacteria, but easily scratched |
|
Scratch Resistance |
Best scratch resistance |
Can scratch - can be sanded and repaired |
Highly scratch resistant — small scratches can be professionally repaired |
Can be scratched - not easily repaired |
Scratches and abrasions can usually be sanded out |
|
Fabrication |
May require seams — various edge profiles available |
Seamless - usually set on a wood sub-structure - various edge profiles available |
May require seams - various edge profiles available |
Sheet material is applied to a wood sub-structure - limited edge profiles |
Wood blanks can be custom made into many shapes and edge types |
|
Appearance |
Polished finish - consistent and uniform color and patterning |
Matte finish — with consistent and uniform color and patterning |
Highly polished finish — every piece is naturally unique in color and patterning |
Highly visible seams — consistent and uniform color and cvpatterning |
Can be oiled or vanished depending on the application and intended look |
|
Strength and Cracking Resistance |
Strongest of all. Can be unsupported for 24". |
Solid Surface — Medium strong, but highly resistant to cracking. |
Very strong, but natural fissures and faults require very good and level support |
Wooden substrate supports tde laminate which itself is quite flimsy. If installed properly, very strong and crack resistant. Seams can expand over time if not sealed. |
Very strong, but cracks can form in dry climate. |
|
Maintenance |
None — ever. |
Scratches can be sanded out |
Requires periodic sealing to prevent staining |
Oil finish needs reapplied approx every 6 weeks |
|
|
Price |
$60 - $80 per sq/ft |
$50 - $65 per sq/ft |
$35 sq/ft and up |
Inexpensive |
Price various by species of wood |
